Edinburgh offers several fantastic neighborhoods for travelers. All the areas highlighted below are great choices – each has its own charm, so it’s about finding the best fit for your style. The city’s layout is compact and easy to navigate. The historic Old Town and elegant New Town form the central core, separated by the gardens along Princes Street. Most major attractions are within walking distance if you stay in or near the center. For areas further out like Leith, frequent buses (and trams) link them to the center, so you’re never too disconnected. In short, Edinburgh is very walkable and well-connected, making all these neighborhoods accessible and enjoyable.

Old Town

Edinburgh’s Old Town is the medieval heart of the city, famous for its cobbled streets, narrow alleys, and historic architecture. The Royal Mile – the mile-long street from Edinburgh Castle to Holyrood Palace – runs through the center of Old Town and is lined with centuries-old buildings, museums, and pubs. This area feels like a step back in time and contains most of Edinburgh’s must-see sights, from the Castle and St. Giles’ Cathedral to the National Museum of Scotland. Despite being lively by day with tourists and street performers, Old Town can be peaceful at night in the smaller side streets. Staying here means you are in the middle of the action – an ideal base for sightseeing on foot.

Best suited for:

• First-time visitors to Edinburgh (it’s the city’s “heart” and main tourist area)
• History buffs and architecture lovers who want to soak up medieval atmosphere
• Travelers who plan to do a lot of sightseeing and want attractions right on their doorstep
• Families with children (the storybook setting captivates kids, feeling like a film set at times)

Best areas to stay in Old Town:

• Royal Mile and adjacent closes – Staying along the Royal Mile (High Street) puts you steps away from major attractions and historic landmarks. You’ll have charming old buildings and cafes at your door, though note this street is very busy during the day.
• Grassmarket – A vibrant square just below the Castle, with many pubs, restaurants, and a local market. Grassmarket offers a lively evening scene and great Castle views. It’s still central but slightly removed from the heaviest tourist foot traffic on the Royal Mile.
• Upper Old Town near the Castle – The area around Castlehill/Lawnmarket is extremely convenient for sightseeing (right by the Castle). In the evenings it’s quieter once the tourists clear out, though there are a few traditional pubs tucked away.

Areas to avoid staying in Old Town:

• Cowgate late-night area – Cowgate and the immediate surrounding streets can get loud and rowdy at night due to bars and nightclubs. If you prefer quiet, avoid accommodations directly above or adjacent to busy pubs and clubs here (especially on weekends).
• High-up closes and steep lanes – Old Town is hilly. Some hotels/B&Bs lie up steep closes (alleyways with stairs). If you have mobility issues or heavy luggage, you may want to avoid lodging that requires climbing lots of steps to reach. Stick to main streets or ask about elevator access.

Pros of Old Town:

• Unbeatable central location: You can walk to the vast majority of Edinburgh’s attractions within minutes. For example, the Castle, Royal Mile sights, and many museums are right there.
• Historic charm: Old Town’s medieval architecture and ambiance are uniquely atmospheric. It’s full of historic buildings that really give you a sense of Edinburgh’s past.
• Lively and entertaining: There are plenty of pubs, restaurants, shops, and things to do packed into Old Town. Street performances and festivals here (especially in August) add to the energy.
• Variety of accommodations: Despite the area’s old-world character, there are lodging options for every budget – from hostels and budget inns to luxury boutique hotels. (However, prices are generally higher here than elsewhere.)
• Transport convenience: Edinburgh Waverley, the main train station, is on the edge of Old Town (between Old and New Town), and many bus routes start nearby – so day trips and airport transfers are easy.

Cons of Old Town:

• Tourist crowds: As the most popular area, Old Town gets very crowded in peak season. Expect busy streets and queues at major sights. During the summer festivals, it’s packed shoulder-to-shoulder.
• Higher prices: Accommodation and dining in this prime tourist area tend to be the most expensive in Edinburgh. You pay a premium for the location. (By comparison, hotels in the New Town are often a bit cheaper for similar standards.)
• Noise in some spots: While many side lanes are quiet, the main streets and party hotspots can be noisy at night. Streets like Cowgate or parts of the Royal Mile have late-night revelers – light sleepers should choose their location carefully.
• Hills and stairs: Old Town’s terrain is steep and uneven. Walking around involves climbing hills or stairs (e.g. the “Royal Mile” slopes downward, and there are many closes with steps). This can be tiring for some travelers.
• Older buildings: Hotels here are often in historic buildings, which means rooms might be smaller, with no lift, or without air conditioning (which isn’t usually needed, but worth noting). Modern amenities can be limited in some lower-budget Old Town properties due to the age of structures.

Average prices in Old Town (per night, year-round average):

• Budget: ~£70 (≈$90) – This is for basic guesthouses or hostels in Old Town. (In Edinburgh generally, a double room rarely goes below £60, and in Old Town you may pay a bit above that for the location.)
• Mid-range: ~£130 (≈$170) – Approximate nightly rate for a mid-level hotel in Old Town. Many mid-range central hotels across Edinburgh average around £100, but in Old Town expect to spend a bit more for the prime location.
• Luxury: ~£250 (≈$330) – Top-end hotels in or around Old Town (boutique 5-star properties, etc.) often average in this range. During high season, luxury options can be even more, while in low season it might be a bit less. (Note: Prices can double in August due to festivals.)

New Town

Just north of Old Town (across Princes Street Gardens) lies the Georgian-era New Town. This district was planned in the 18th–19th centuries, featuring grand neoclassical architecture, wide streets, and elegant squares. In contrast to Old Town’s medieval maze, New Town feels more orderly and spacious. It’s known for excellent shopping and dining: Princes Street is the main shopping street (with high-street shops and views of the Castle), while George Street is home to upscale boutiques and chic cocktail bars. You’ll also find many cafes, restaurants, and pubs tucked along Rose Street, Queen Street, and Thistle Street. Major cultural sites like the Scottish National Gallery and Scott Monument are in New Town as well. Overall, New Town offers a blend of historic elegance and modern convenience, all within easy reach of the Old Town (just a 5–10 minute walk across the bridge).

Best suited for:

• Travelers who want a central location but a slightly quieter or more polished atmosphere than Old Town
• Shoppers and foodies – New Town is great for retail therapy and has lots of high-quality restaurants and bars
• Those interested in Georgian architecture and a more “local” city vibe (office workers, local residents frequent this area, not just tourists)
• Nightlife seekers who prefer trendy bars or clubs – New Town’s George Street has many stylish bars and some nightlife, albeit more upscale than Old Town’s pub scene
• Budget-conscious travelers who want to stay central – New Town hotels can be slightly less expensive on average than similar ones in Old Town due to a bit less tourist demand

Best areas to stay in New Town:

• Princes Street vicinity – Staying on or just off Princes Street puts you right by the main shops and transportation (buses and trams). It’s extremely convenient and you’ll have the beautiful skyline of Old Town across the gardens. Keep in mind Princes Street is busy all day with traffic and shoppers, so not the quietest spot, but you can’t beat the access to everything.
• George Street & Queen Street – These parallel streets run through the heart of New Town and are lined with boutiques, restaurants, and nightlife. Accommodations around here will have you close to dining and evening hangouts. George Street is lively in the evenings with bars, while Queen Street is a bit quieter and borders the scenic Queen Street Gardens.
• Broughton Street / St. James Quarter (East New Town) – The east end of New Town (around Broughton Street and the new St. James shopping centre) is a great area for a slightly more local feel. Broughton Street, in particular, is one of locals’ favorite streets with lots of pubs and eateries. Staying around here gives you easy access to the city centre plus a taste of neighborhood life. The York Place tram stop is nearby for direct airport access.
• West End of New Town (Charlotte Square) – On the western edge of New Town, near Charlotte Square, you’ll find a mix of luxury hotels and quieter streets. This area is adjacent to the West End; staying here means you can easily explore both New Town and the West End/Dean Village. It’s a refined area with embassies and townhouses.

Areas to avoid staying in New Town:
(New Town is generally very safe and convenient; there are no “bad” parts of New Town, but a few considerations when choosing lodging)

• Far north residential areas: New Town proper ends around Queen Street or a bit beyond. If you go too far north (toward areas like Canonmills or Ferry Road), you’re leaving the central area. Unless you find a specific reason to stay there, it might be too far a walk. Try to stay within a 15-minute walk of Princes Street for a true New Town base (beyond that, you lose some convenience and atmosphere).
• Princes Street itself for light sleepers: While convenient, Princes Street is a busy thoroughfare (buses, trams, and late-night traffic). Very few hotels are directly on it, but if yours is, be aware of potential noise or ask for a higher-floor room. An alternative is to stay just one block in (George or Queen Street) for a quieter night.
• Office districts at night: Some parts of New Town (particularly the far west end around the Haymarket side, or the immediate area around St Andrew Square after hours) can feel a bit empty at night once offices close. This isn’t dangerous, but if you prefer some buzz in the evening, you might avoid those strictly business blocks and stay nearer to mixed-use streets with restaurants or pubs.

Pros of New Town:

• Central and walkable: New Town is directly adjacent to Old Town – it’s super central. You can walk to virtually all main sights (either within New Town or over to Old Town) easily. It’s also flat compared to Old Town, making walks easier.
• Beautiful architecture: The Georgian architecture of New Town is a UNESCO World Heritage highlight. The streets are elegant with grand facades and crescents. Fans of architecture or photography will love the classy, historic look of the area.
• Great shopping & dining: New Town is the place for shopping in Edinburgh, from high-end boutiques to department stores. There are also countless cafes, restaurants, and bars – you’ll find everything from traditional pubs to trendy cocktail lounges here.
• Wide range of hotels: You’ll generally find more mid-range and chain hotels in New Town than in Old Town, which is good for value. There’s something for every budget, including familiar hotel brands and also luxury options. (Many highly-rated hotels are in this area, so you can often find good deals outside of peak season.)
• Transportation hub: Staying in New Town puts you near major transport links. Edinburgh Waverley station sits at the edge of New Town, and the Edinburgh Tram (to the airport) terminates here as well. Numerous bus routes start from Princes Street and George Street. This makes day trips or airport transfers very convenient.

Cons of New Town:

• Less old-world charm: While New Town is historic, it’s “only” 200-250 years old and more cosmopolitan in feel. It doesn’t have the ancient, quirky character of Old Town’s medieval streets. Some travelers seeking a very old-time ambiance might find New Town a bit too modern or polished in comparison.
• Busy commercial areas: Sections of New Town (Princes St, parts of George St) are commercial hubs, so you’ll encounter rush-hour crowds, shoppers, and traffic. It’s not as tourist-crowded as the Royal Mile, but it’s bustling in daytime.
• Nightlife noise in specific spots: Conversely, while much of New Town is quieter at night, the bar areas like George Street can get noisy late at night on weekends. If your hotel is near a popular bar/club, you might hear revelers or music at closing time.
• Fewer tourist attractions within the neighborhood: Apart from the galleries, monuments, and a few museums, most “big” attractions (Castle, Royal Mile, etc.) are in Old Town. That means you will be walking across to Old Town frequently. This is a minor con since the walk is short, but you won’t step out of your hotel and see castles immediately (you’ll see beautiful streets and parks instead).
• Spread-out feel: Because New Town’s streets are broad and orderly, some people find it has a less intimate atmosphere. The buildings are also taller Georgian tenements, so you don’t get the cozy closes or courtyards as in Old Town. It’s a matter of preference – New Town feels more like a “classic European city,” whereas Old Town feels uniquely medieval.

Average prices in New Town: (Generally slightly lower than Old Town)

• Budget: ~£60 (≈$80) – per night for budget hotels or guesthouses. New Town has some hostels and 2-star hotels where you might even find rates around this level. Many travelers find better budget deals here than in Old Town.
• Mid-range: ~£120 (≈$160) – per night for a comfortable 3–4★ hotel. This is around the city’s average for a mid-range central hotel. You can often get a nice mid-range room in New Town a bit cheaper than the equivalent in Old Town, making it good value.
• Luxury: ~£220 (≈$290) – per night for high-end hotels. New Town has several luxury hotels (including five-star options), and their prices tend to be slightly lower than Old Town’s top hotels. Still, expect to pay a premium for famous luxury properties (e.g. The Balmoral, an iconic New Town hotel, can be above this range).

West End (including Haymarket & Dean Village)

West of New Town’s core is the West End, an affluent area known for its mix of cultural sites, beautiful architecture, and convenient transport links. This area spans roughly from the western end of Princes Street (around Shandwick Place and Charlotte Square) out to Haymarket Station and up to the charming Dean Village by the Water of Leith. The West End is sometimes considered part of New Town, but it has its own character: quieter residential streets with stunning Victorian townhouses, embassies, and boutique hotels. It’s home to venues like the Usher Hall (Edinburgh’s main concert hall) and the Edinburgh International Conference Centre (EICC), as well as art attractions like the Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art (a short walk away). Haymarket, on the western edge, is a transport hub with a train and tram station, making it ultra-convenient for getting around. This area offers a nice balance – you’re still within walking distance of Princes Street (about 10–15 minutes), but you escape the busiest tourist crowds. Many locals live and work around the West End, so it has a more authentic everyday atmosphere while still feeling very central.

Best suited for:

• Travelers seeking a balance between central location and a quieter stay. If you want to be near the sights but not in the thick of the tourist hubbub at night, the West End is ideal.
• Budget-conscious visitors who don’t mind a short walk – this area has several hotels that are more affordable than the absolute city-center options, yet it’s only a short walk or tram ride away from the action.
• Those arriving by train or plane: Haymarket Station (in the West End) is a major stop for trains and the Edinburgh tram line to the airport. Staying here is very handy if you have an early train or want a quick ride to the airport.
• Visitors interested in culture and events – you’ll be near theaters (like Usher Hall, Traverse Theatre) and the conference center. Also good for rugby or events at Murrayfield Stadium (one tram stop away).
• Repeat visitors or people who prefer a more local vibe. West End has residential pockets, local pubs, and indie shops that give you a taste of real Edinburgh life beyond the tourist zones.
• Photographers/peace-seekers – Dean Village, in this area, is a picturesque historic mill village with cobbled lanes and is extremely photogenic. If you love scenic strolls, having Dean Village and the Water of Leith on your doorstep is a plus.

Best areas to stay in West End:

• Near Haymarket – The blocks immediately around Haymarket Station and along Haymarket Terrace have many hotels (including new or renovated ones) that often cost less than city-centre equivalents. You’ll have superb transport (train to Glasgow, tram to airport, many buses). From Haymarket, it’s an easy 10-minute walk or 5-minute tram to Princes Street. This area has quite a few restaurants and pubs catering to locals and travelers. (Staying just off the main road can be quieter, but still very convenient.)
• West End village (Atholl/Stafford Streets) – Tucked between Shandwick Place and Melville Street, the West End “village” area has quaint streets with boutiques, cafes, and beautiful architecture. For example, around William Street, Stafford Street, and Melville Street – you’ll feel like you’re in a upscale residential area with charm. It’s quieter at night, and still only ~5-10 min walk to the west end of Princes Street.
• Lothian Road & Shandwick Place – The eastern fringe of the West End near Lothian Road (which leads toward the Castle and Old Town) is great if you want to be very close to the main sights while technically being in the West End. There are hotels around here that position you between Old Town and West End. Lothian Road has lots of dining (from quick eats to upscale) and nightlife, plus it’s right by Princes Street Gardens and Edinburgh Castle’s west approach. This area is a bit busier and more commercial, but very convenient for a short trip.
• Dean Village vicinity – If you prefer a beautiful, tranquil setting, consider lodging near Dean Village or the western end of Queensferry Road. Dean Village is a tiny historic enclave on the Water of Leith, with storybook-like old houses. There are a couple of hotels and B&Bs on the fringes of Dean Village and toward Belford Road. You’ll be ~10 minutes walk from the West End proper, but in exchange you get lovely river views and peace. This is great for a romantic stay or for those who enjoy morning jogs along the river. (Note: Dean Village itself is largely residential; any accommodation will be just outside it, as the village is protected.)

Areas to avoid staying in West End:

• Right on the Haymarket junction: Haymarket is a busy convergence of main roads and tram lines. The immediate intersection can be noisy with traffic virtually all day. If you’re staying in the Haymarket area, you might avoid hotels that are exactly on the corner of the station junction, especially if you’re sensitive to noise or exhaust. One or two blocks away (toward the West End side streets) can make a big difference in quietness and atmosphere.
• Farther West (beyond Haymarket): If you go past Haymarket, you get into purely residential districts like Dalry or toward Murrayfield. Unless you specifically need to be near the stadium or have an Airbnb out there, it’s not ideal for short-term visitors – you’d be adding extra transit time and there’s little tourist infrastructure. Try to stay on the city side of Haymarket Station for convenience.
• Fountainbridge (southwest of West End): While not “bad,” Fountainbridge is more of a business and new-development area with offices and modern flats. It’s about 15-20 min walk from Princes Street. If your focus is sightseeing and charm, Fountainbridge might feel a bit out-of-the-way and bland. You can find good deals there, but be aware you’re on the fringe; you might prefer to stay closer to the core of West End around Melville/Stafford Streets instead.

Pros of West End:

• Close to city center, but calmer: You remain within easy walking distance of major attractions (only 10-15 minutes to the center). But the streets (especially off the main roads) are calmer at night. It’s a nice break from the tourist throngs – you can relax in a neighborhood setting and still be near everything.
• More affordable accommodations: The West End/Haymarket area is known for having good hotels at lower rates than Old Town/New Town center. You often get better value for money here. (For instance, a hotel in Haymarket might be significantly cheaper than a comparable one on the Royal Mile.)
• Excellent transport links: Haymarket Station is a major plus – trains, trams, and buses radiate from here. If you plan day trips by train or need quick airport access, this is the place. Multiple bus routes and the tram line make it very easy to reach other parts of the city or the airport. You might even save on cabs because of how well-connected it is.
• Authentic local feel: Staying here, you’ll see a slice of local Edinburgh life. There are local pubs, grocery stores, and less tourist-centric shops around. The atmosphere is more “liveable city” than tourist zone, which many enjoy for a longer stay. You can dine at neighborhood restaurants and mingle with residents.
• Beautiful architecture & scenery: The West End boasts lovely Georgian and Victorian architecture – townhouses, churches, and crescents. Plus, you have Dean Village and the Water of Leith on the edge, offering scenic walks (you can walk through Dean Village all the way to Stockbridge along a riverside path). Princes Street Gardens are also right there for a green space to relax.
• Cultural attractions: You’ll be close to several cultural sites: the Modern Art Galleries (a short walk or bus), Dean Gallery, and concert venues. In August, some festival events take place around the West End too. It’s a good area if you’re in town for a festival or event and want to stay near those venues.

Cons of West End:

• A short commute to Old Town: While 10-15 minutes walking is nothing major, you won’t be right next to, say, the Royal Mile. If you anticipate going back and forth to your hotel throughout the day, being slightly removed could be a minor inconvenience. (However, the walk or a quick bus often suffices for most.)
• Less nightlife and tourist dining: The West End has some nice pubs and restaurants, but it’s not as packed with options as Old Town or New Town. Late at night, the area is fairly quiet. If you want vibrant nightlife every evening, you might end up walking to the Old Town or George Street.
• Traffic on main roads: The flipside of good transport is the traffic. Haymarket and the west end of Princes Street can be busy with cars, buses, and trams. The noise and bustle are mostly confined to the main arteries, but it’s something to note if you stay on those roads.
• Fewer “famous” sights in immediate vicinity: The West End itself doesn’t have big-name attractions (aside from maybe Dean Village and Scott Monument nearby). Most sights are either in Old Town or New Town, or farther out. If you love the idea of stepping out of your hotel and seeing a historic site straight away, you won’t quite get that here. You’ll have a short walk first.
• Potential for older accommodation stock: Some budget hotels in this area used to have a reputation (years ago) for being a bit tired. The good news is many have been renovated recently. Still, if you opt for the absolute cheapest place in West End, read recent reviews to ensure it meets expectations – the quality can vary from lovely boutique hotels to very basic inns.

Average prices in West End/Haymarket:

• Budget: ~£50 (≈$65) – You can often find simple hotels or B&Bs in the Haymarket area around this price, especially outside of peak summer. This is notably cheaper than the same in Old Town. Even some well-known chain hotels here can dip to ~£50-£70 in off-season.
• Mid-range: ~£100 (≈$130) – Plenty of solid 3-4★ hotels in the West End fall in this range on average. For example, a modern hotel by Haymarket might cost about £90-£110 per night year-round, which is good value for Edinburgh.
• Luxury: ~£180 (≈$240) – The West End has a couple of upscale options (like classic 4★ boutique hotels in Georgian buildings). These tend to be cheaper than equivalent luxury in the city center. Around £180 is a typical average; however, one of Edinburgh’s top luxury hotels, the Waldorf Astoria (Caledonian Hotel), sits at West End’s edge and can cost well above £200. Aside from that, most “luxury” in this area is in the high £100s range.

Stockbridge

Stockbridge is a delightful neighborhood located about 1 mile north of Edinburgh’s city centre. Often described as having a “village” feel, Stockbridge is an upscale yet bohemian area known for its independent shops, cozy cafes, and community vibe. Here you’ll find art galleries, vintage boutiques, artisan grocery stores, and one of Edinburgh’s best Sunday farmers’ markets. The pace of life is a bit slower than downtown – it’s the kind of place locals come for a Sunday stroll by the river or to browse the weekend market. Stockbridge is set along the Water of Leith, and a picturesque path follows the river, connecting to nearby Dean Village and the Royal Botanic Garden. This area is largely residential (with beautiful Georgian and Victorian terraces), so accommodation options are fewer and tend to be smaller boutique hotels or guesthouses. Staying in Stockbridge gives you a taste of local Edinburgh charm in an “urban village” setting, while still being close enough to reach the main sights with a short walk or bus ride.

Best suited for:

• “Live like a local” travelers: If you enjoy immersing yourself in local neighborhoods – visiting markets, small pubs, and coffee shops where residents hang out – Stockbridge is perfect. It’s not a typical tourist zone, which is its appeal.
• Return visitors or slower-paced itineraries: Those who have seen the main attractions before, or anyone who wants a more relaxed visit, will appreciate Stockbridge. It’s great for experiencing Edinburgh beyond the postcard sights.
• Foodies and cafe lovers: Stockbridge has a high concentration of quality cafes, bakeries, and specialty food shops, as well as some excellent restaurants and gastro-pubs. It’s known for its Sunday market with delicious street food and local produce.
• Families and mature travelers: The area is safe, residential, and has parks and playgrounds (Inverleith Park, for example). The quieter nights and spacious surroundings can be very welcome for families or older travelers who prefer calm over nightlife.
• Longer stays: If you’re in Edinburgh for an extended period (a week or more), basing in Stockbridge can be ideal. You get a full neighborhood experience and can still get to the center easily when needed.
• Fans of boutique shops: From antique shops to bookstores and clothing boutiques, Stockbridge’s shopping is unique and away from the chain stores. It’s great for finding one-of-a-kind souvenirs or just window-shopping in a charming setting.

Best areas to stay in Stockbridge:

• Raeburn Place (Stockbridge Center): The main street of Stockbridge is Raeburn Place, and staying around here puts you in the heart of the neighborhood. You’ll step out to pubs, cafes, a supermarket, and the weekend market on Saunders Street. It’s lively in the day and pleasantly quiet at night. Accommodations here would have you closest to the action (for example, a boutique hotel on Raeburn Place or St. Stephen Street).
• Along the Water of Leith: If you find a B&B or apartment along the river (near Deanhaugh Street or Kerr Street), you’ll enjoy scenic views and a tranquil atmosphere. You’ll also be conveniently between Stockbridge center and the path towards Dean Village. Waking up near the Water of Leith and walking the riverside trail is a lovely perk of this location.
• Near New Town border (St. Stephen/Howe Street area): The south-east edge of Stockbridge bleeds into New Town around St. Stephen’s Street and Howe Street. Staying here can be smart if you want to be as close as possible to the city centre while still adjacent to Stockbridge. You can easily walk up the hill into New Town’s Queen Street in 5-10 minutes, while also walking down into Stockbridge in 5 minutes. (Note: this involves St. Stephen’s stairs, a steep set of steps connecting New Town down to Stockbridge – a thing to consider if mobility is a concern.) Staying on this edge gives you the best of both worlds: New Town and Stockbridge at your fingertips.

Areas to avoid staying in Stockbridge:

• Beyond Comely Bank: Comely Bank is the northern extension of Stockbridge – a nice residential area, but if you go too far (towards Fettes or Craigleith), you’ll be quite far from the cafés and bus routes. If browsing accommodations, ensure the location is truly in the Stockbridge vicinity (around 5-10 minutes walk of Raeburn Place). Anything much further out might be inconvenient unless you have a car.
• Ensure proximity to transport: Stockbridge itself doesn’t have a train or tram, so you’ll rely on walking or buses. It’s wise to stay near main roads like Raeburn Place or Kerr Street where buses pass. If you stay deep inside the residential side streets, it’s perfectly fine, but you may have a longer walk to catch a bus or taxi. In general, avoid places marketed as “Stockbridge” that are actually over 1 km away from the heart of it.
• No real “unsafe” areas: There really aren’t bad parts of Stockbridge – it’s uniformly a safe, affluent district. The only caution is the hill: if you have trouble with hills, you might avoid accommodations at the very top of Stockbridge (like towards Howe Street) because going up and down to Stockbridge could be strenuous. Otherwise, there’s no specific part of Stockbridge one must avoid on safety grounds; it’s all quite pleasant and well-to-do.

Pros of Stockbridge:

• Village atmosphere: Stockbridge offers a charming small-town feel within the city. The community vibe is strong – you’ll see locals walking dogs, families out for ice cream, people chatting at the Sunday market. It feels very welcoming and homey.
• Independent shops & market: You can spend leisurely days exploring the unique boutiques, from cheese mongers to vintage shops. The Sunday farmers’ market is a highlight, full of local vendors. It’s a great way to experience Edinburgh’s local food scene.
• Dining and cafes: The area is packed with highly-rated cafes and eateries. Whether it’s brunch in a cozy café, a vegan bakery, or a classic pub (like The Stockbridge Tap or Hector’s), you have lots of choices in a small radius. You won’t go hungry here, and it’s easy to find a nice coffee or pastry steps from your door.
• Green spaces and scenery: Stockbridge is adjacent to the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh (a lovely attraction in its own right) and Inverleith Park, which has open fields and views of the city skyline. The Water of Leith flows through the area, providing a peaceful nature walk. This access to greenery is a big plus in an urban stay – you can relax by the river or picnic in the park on nice days.
• Still accessible to centre: Although it’s a bit removed, Stockbridge is only about a 15-20 minute walk to Princes Street/New Town and about 25-30 minute walk to the Old Town. There are also frequent buses (the ride to the city centre is ~10 minutes). So you can easily reach the main tourist sites when you want, then retreat back to the quieter neighborhood in the evening. It offers a good balance of distance and accessibility.
• High-quality accommodations (albeit few): The accommodations that do exist in Stockbridge tend to be well-reviewed – often small boutique hotels or guesthouses that pride themselves on personal service. As one guide notes, Stockbridge’s lodgings are few but high quality, so you have a good chance of a pleasant stay.

Cons of Stockbridge:

• Not in the thick of tourist sights: If your priority is to step out of your hotel and immediately be at a famous attraction, Stockbridge will disappoint. You will need to walk or bus to get to the Royal Mile, Castle, etc. It’s a trade-off for the neighborhood charm.
• Limited accommodation choices: Because Stockbridge is primarily residential, there are relatively few hotels. They can book up early, especially in high season. You might not have as many options in different price ranges – for example, there are no large budget hostels right in Stockbridge (most budget travelers stay in centre and just visit Stockbridge for the day). If you require a wide selection of hotels or big-brand hotels, you won’t find that here.
• Nightlife and late dining: In the evening, Stockbridge is calm. There are some pubs and restaurants, but this is not the area for nightlife or clubbing. Things tend to wind down earlier. If you want to party until late, you’ll likely have to head to another area and then taxi back.
• Hill to city centre: The walk back from New Town to Stockbridge involves going downhill or uphill (depending on direction). Particularly, coming from Princes Street, you descend quite a long staircase (or a steep road) into Stockbridge. It’s fine for the reasonably fit, but it could be an annoyance if done repeatedly. There’s no avoiding the topography – just be aware that it’s not flat between Stockbridge and the central area.
• Expense of eateries: While there are cheap eats around, Stockbridge is a relatively affluent area, and many shops and cafes reflect that. Prices in independent boutiques or organic markets might be higher than average. Dining out here can be a bit pricier than in student areas like Southside, for instance. This isn’t a deal-breaker, but budget travelers should pick their spots (or self-cater using the local grocery) to avoid overspending.
• Mostly flats (if considering Airbnb): If you are thinking of apartment rentals, note that many buildings are classic tenements – beautiful, but sometimes 3rd or 4th floor with no elevator. Also parking is limited if you had a car. This is just something to keep in mind if not using hotels. In hotels/B&Bs specifically, check if there’s an elevator if stairs are an issue, since many are converted old houses.

Average prices in Stockbridge:

• Budget: ~£60 (≈$80) – There are a handful of budget-friendly guesthouses/B&Bs around Stockbridge or on its fringes. Expect around £60-£80 for a basic private room in this area (when available). It’s slightly above the absolute cheapest in the city because of limited supply, but you can find a decent deal considering the location.
• Mid-range: ~£110 (≈$145) – Most accommodations in Stockbridge will fall into this mid-range category (e.g. small boutique hotels, guesthouse rooms). Around £100-£120 is the average nightly cost for a well-appointed room. This is comparable to city-centre mid-range prices, so you’re not necessarily saving money by staying here – you’re choosing it for the vibe.
• Luxury: ~£170 (≈$225) – Stockbridge isn’t big on large luxury hotels, but it does have a couple of upscale boutique hotels. These tend to be in historic buildings with stylish furnishings, etc. Prices for the top rooms or suites in the area average around £170 or so per night. If you were to find a high-end serviced apartment here, it might also fall in this range. (For context, this is a bit lower than Old/New Town luxury averages, since the ultra-5-star brands are not in Stockbridge.)

Leith

Leith is Edinburgh’s vibrant port district, located to the north of the city centre along the shore of the Firth of Forth. Historically, Leith was a separate port town – it has a distinct identity and character shaped by its maritime past. In recent decades, Leith has transformed from a rough-around-the-edges docklands into one of the city’s trendiest neighborhoods. It’s often touted as the “hip” part of Edinburgh, full of creative energy, diverse communities, and a famed food and drink scene. Leith is sizeable, but the area of most interest to visitors centers around The Shore (the waterfront area where the Water of Leith meets the sea). Here you’ll find cobbled quays, old warehouses converted into restaurants, traditional pubs, and modern cocktail bars side by side. Leith is known for having some of Edinburgh’s best restaurants, including several Michelin-starred eateries, as well as trendy cafes, live music bars, and galleries. It’s a place where you can have an excellent seafood dinner, then grab a craft beer in a stylish bar, all away from the tourist crowds.

Staying in Leith offers a very authentic and contemporary Edinburgh experience – you’re mingling with locals in one of the city’s most happening areas. It was even voted one of the world’s coolest neighborhoods in a Time Out survey in 2021. Do note: Leith is about 2–3 miles from the central Old Town. Reaching the city centre requires a bus, tram or taxi (about 15-20 minutes by transit). The payoff is a unique waterfront vibe and typically better prices on hotels and food. Leith combines history (you can sense the old port atmosphere) with modern culture (street art, indie businesses, multicultural community), making it a fascinating area to stay.

Best suited for:

• Foodies and craft beer/whisky lovers: Leith’s dining scene is top-notch, ranging from upscale restaurants to trendy brunch spots. If sampling Edinburgh’s best restaurants and cool bars is a priority, Leith is the place. It attracts hipsters and foodies from all over the city.
• Nightlife seekers (local style): While Leith doesn’t have big nightclubs, it has a lively evening scene with many pubs (some featuring live music or pub quizzes) and stylish bars. It’s great for a night out with locals, away from the more touristy pubs of the Old Town.
• Culturally curious travelers: Those who want to see a different side of Edinburgh beyond the historic centre will enjoy Leith. It’s a neighborhood with its own story, arts scene, and even unique attractions like the Royal Yacht Britannia (the former royal yacht, now a museum ship, docked at Leith’s Ocean Terminal).
• Young couples or friend groups: Leith’s mix of trendy and budget-friendly can appeal to younger travelers. You’ll find cool boutique hotels or apartments here that might suit a youthful aesthetic. Plus, the area’s edgy reputation (thanks to Trainspotting fame) and subsequent renaissance give it a cool cachet.
• Longer-stay travelers and digital nomads: Because it’s less touristy, Leith can feel more like “living in Edinburgh.” If you’re staying a bit longer or working remotely, you might appreciate the community feel, local cafes to work from, and possibly larger apartment-style accommodations for lower cost.
• Budget travelers: Generally, accommodations and eateries in Leith offer better value. If you don’t mind the short commute, you can save money by staying here versus the city centre. It’s a good trade-off for budget-conscious travelers who prefer a private room or nicer hostel at lower cost.
• Return visitors: If you’ve already done Edinburgh’s main sights, staying in Leith on a subsequent trip gives you a fresh perspective of the city, almost like visiting a “new” city within Edinburgh. Many repeat visitors end up loving Leith for its authentic feel.

Best areas to stay in Leith:

• The Shore: This is the heart of Leith’s social scene. The Shore area (around Commercial Street, Shore, and Coalhill) is where the Water of Leith opens into the port. It’s a picturesque area with boats, waterfront promenades, and many popular restaurants/bars. Staying here means you can walk to dinner or drinks along the waterfront every evening. It’s arguably the most charming part of Leith – think converted whisky warehouses, seafood bistros, and twinkling lights by the water. Accommodations here include boutique hotels and serviced apartments. The Shore is cosy and highly recommended to visitors looking to see another side of the city​.
• Leith Walk & Constitution Street: Leith Walk is the long avenue that links central Edinburgh to Leith. The upper part of Leith Walk (closer to town) is more urban and mixed-use, while the lower part (near Leith) has a lot of shops, cafes, and theaters (like Leith Theatre). Staying somewhere along Leith Walk (especially the lower half, near Constitution Street or Pilrig) can be convenient – you’re roughly halfway between Leith’s waterfront and the New Town. There are numerous guesthouses, B&Bs, and budget hotels on or just off Leith Walk. The new tram extension also runs up Leith Walk and down Constitution Street, giving direct tram access to the city centre and airport from this area. It’s a good option if you want affordability and connectivity. (Tip: the closer to The Shore/Constitution Street end, the more “Leith” vibe you get; the closer to Pilrig, the easier to reach downtown quickly.)
• Around Ocean Terminal/Newhaven: At the northern edge of Leith is Ocean Terminal (a shopping center) and the Newhaven harbor area. Here you’ll find the Royal Yacht Britannia attraction. There are a couple of hotels in this vicinity (including chain hotels). It’s a quieter area to stay, mainly suited if you want free parking or plan to use Britannia/Ocean Terminal often. It’s less atmospheric than The Shore, but still has waterfront views. Newhaven, just west of Ocean Terminal, is a small historic fishing village area with a picturesque harbour and a few seafood restaurants – staying near Newhaven can be pleasant in summer. Keep in mind, though, this is getting a bit further from central Leith and certainly far from downtown (you’d rely on bus/tram). For most travelers without a car, we’d recommend focusing on The Shore or Leith Walk areas first.

Areas to avoid staying in Leith:

• Inland Leith backstreets: Leith is generally safe nowadays, but some streets can vary in character literally from one to the next​. As a visitor, you might want to avoid booking accommodation on very isolated or run-down side streets in Leith that you’re unfamiliar with. Sticking to the main areas (shoreline, main roads like Leith Walk) is usually a better experience. For example, streets deep in the residential parts of Leith (away from The Shore or main roads) might feel quite deserted at night and lack nearby amenities. Research the exact address of your lodging – if reviews mention the area feels sketchy at night, take note.
• Upper Leith Walk at night: The upper stretch of Leith Walk (around Pilrig to Elm Row) has a few adult entertainment venues and can get a bit rowdy on weekend nights. It’s not really dangerous, but the environment might feel less comfortable for some (with groups of people outside bars, etc.). If you’re a solo traveler or simply prefer a very calm surrounding at night, you might avoid staying right on that part of Leith Walk. Lower down in Leith and The Shore tend to have a friendlier vibe at night with folks out enjoying pubs/restaurants.
• Far north industrial areas: A few accommodations might market themselves as “Leith” but are actually out by industrial estates or docks (for example, toward Granton or Seafield). These areas are not convenient for tourists and have no charm – mainly trucking depots, warehouses, etc. Avoid staying in such zones unless you have a specific reason. They offer little beyond perhaps a lower price, which usually isn’t worth the trade-off in isolation.
• No-go zones: Leith no longer has any truly dangerous no-go zones – the days of Trainspotting-style notoriety are over​. Nonetheless, like any urban area, it’s wise to avoid unlit parks or very quiet alleys late at night. Use basic city smarts. The central parts of Leith (around Shore and main streets) will have people around even in the evenings, which feels safer and more comfortable.

Pros of Leith:

• Fantastic food & drink scene: Leith is the destination for foodies in Edinburgh. You have everything from Michelin-starred fine dining to quirky coffee shops and multicultural cuisine (Indian, Italian, Scottish seafood, you name it). The diversity and quality in a compact area is hard to beat​. For example, you could eat at a different top-rated restaurant every night in Leith and still have more to try. Likewise, pub enthusiasts will find historic taverns as well as modern brewpubs.
• Trendy, creative vibe: Leith’s “up and coming” status has made it a hub for artists, designers, and young entrepreneurs. This translates into cool art galleries, studios, record shops, street art and murals, and a generally creative atmosphere. There’s an energy here – the feeling of a neighborhood with a lot of local pride and innovation. Time Out ranked it among the world’s coolest neighborhoods for good reason​. Staying here, you get to tap into that local buzz.
• Waterfront charm: Being by the water gives Leith a special ambiance you won’t find in landlocked central Edinburgh. You can walk along the quays and docks, enjoy fresh sea air, and even see some maritime heritage (like old dock cranes, ships, etc.). On a sunny day, sitting by the Shore with a drink is delightful. It offers a semi-maritime getaway feel within the city.
• Rich history (beyond touristy stuff): Leith has a storied history – it was the port where royal ships landed, it has connections to Mary Queen of Scots, and it was an independent burgh for centuries. There are historical sites like the old Customs House, Leith Links (where the rules of golf were first codified), and remnants of defensive walls if you know where to look. While these aren’t blockbuster attractions, history lovers will enjoy exploring the neighborhood’s heritage. The area also played a key role in literature and films (e.g., Trainspotting). It’s “rough around the edges” past is long gone​, but the history remains part of its character.
• Affordability: Generally, prices for both accommodation and dining/entertainment in Leith are lower than in the tourist centre. You might find that your money goes further – whether that means you can afford a nicer hotel for the same price you’d pay for a budget one downtown, or simply save on nightly rates. Likewise, local cafes and bars in Leith often have more reasonable prices. This value for money is a big plus for many travelers.
• Community and authenticity: Leith is very much a living, working community. You’ll be surrounded by residents going about daily life, which can make your stay feel more authentic. Chatting with friendly locals in a Leith pub or at the market can give you insights into Scottish life that you might not get in the more tourist-oriented parts of town. Many locals are proud of Leith’s identity and happy to share tips about their neighborhood.
• Connectivity: Though not in the center, Leith is well-connected. Lothian Buses run frequently between Leith and Princes Street (multiple routes, often 24 hours). The new tram line now extends into Leith (as of 2023), connecting from Leith Ocean Terminal up Leith Walk to the city centre and airport. So, it’s quite easy to get around. You can usually be in the city centre in about 15 minutes by transit. If you enjoy walking, you can also walk from Leith to the centre in about 30-40 minutes, possibly using the scenic Water of Leith walkway part of the way.

Cons of Leith:

• Distance from main attractions: The biggest drawback is that you can’t just step outside and be at Edinburgh Castle or on the Royal Mile. If most of your itinerary is focused on the classic sights, you’ll be commuting each day. This adds time (and a bit of cost) to your day. After a long day of touring, the bus ride back might feel like a chore compared to staying centrally. For a short trip (1-2 days in Edinburgh), this could be inconvenient.
• Urban grit: While much improved, Leith still has touches of grit. You might see a bit more litter or graffiti in some parts. Certain corners might smell of the sea or breweries. It’s not the manicured, postcard Edinburgh – which is both a pro and con. If you expect the entire city to look like Princes Street Gardens, Leith will feel rougher. That said, many find this realness part of its charm. It’s a “bit rough around the edges” but not unsafe​. Just manage expectations that it’s a trendy port district, not a royal borough.
• Nighttime quiet in some spots: Leith’s hotspots are clustered; other parts can be very quiet or dark at night. For instance, if you stay near Ocean Terminal, that area gets deserted after the mall closes. Even around The Shore, weeknights can be fairly calm after restaurant hours. The streets aren’t as well-lit or crowded late at night as central Edinburgh. Some travelers might feel a little isolated walking through quiet docks or streets late. If you stick to main routes and are in a group or pair, it’s usually fine, but solo travelers should stay alert or take a taxi if unsure.
• Lack of big hotels: If you prefer large hotels with extensive amenities (pool, concierge, etc.), Leith has fewer of those. Aside from a couple of chain hotels near Ocean Terminal, most accommodations are smaller scale. This means more personal character but perhaps not the full service one might expect at a big hotel chain. (One exception is the Malmaison on The Shore, which is a full-service boutique hotel in a converted house – quite popular.)
• Public transport dependence: While buses and trams are good, they do add a layer of planning – you need to catch them and be mindful of the schedule (especially late at night, when trams stop and only night buses run hourly). This is a minor hassle, but compared to stumbling back to a Royal Mile hotel at midnight, coordinating a bus from Leith after an evening out requires a bit more effort. Alternatively, taxis/Uber from city centre to Leith are not very expensive (~£10-£15), but it’s an extra expense to consider if you’ll use them often.
• Perception lag: Some older guidebooks or people might still carry the outdated notion that Leith is “dodgy.” You might hear mixed opinions. Rest assured, the area is no longer distinctly dangerous​ – crime is no worse than in the city centre, generally. However, if you tell a local you’re staying in Leith, they might joke about it (based on the past). If you’re sensitive to that or to the remnants of roughness (like seeing a few drunk folks at night or rowdy football fans on match days – Hibernian FC’s stadium is in Leith), it could be a slight downside.
• Not ideal for very short stays or mobility-limited travelers: If you have only one day in Edinburgh or have trouble climbing bus steps, etc., staying central might be more practical. Leith requires that extra transit step that those with mobility issues might find inconvenient (though the tram is wheelchair accessible). Also, for very short visits, you might prefer maximizing time by being in town.

Average prices in Leith:

• Budget: ~£50 (≈$65) – Leith has some of the city’s best budget options. You can find private rooms in guesthouses or budget hotels around this price. Hostels in the area (if any are available) would be even less. Compared to city centre where £60 is about the floor​, Leith can dip slightly lower while still getting a decent room, especially outside of peak season.
• Mid-range: ~£90 (≈$120) – Nightly rates for nice 3★ hotels or apartments in Leith average a bit under what you’d pay in central Edinburgh. Around £80-£100 can often secure a modern, comfortable room (sometimes in a trendy boutique hotel or a well-known chain’s local branch). This is great value for Edinburgh. Many travelers choose Leith for this reason – you might get a waterfront view or a larger room for the same price that would fetch a tiny room in Old Town.
• Luxury: ~£150 (≈$200) – Leith isn’t overflowing with luxury hotels, but there are a couple of unique high-end stays. For example, Fingal, a converted luxury ship hotel moored in Leith, offers a very upscale experience (often around £250-£300/night)​. Aside from such outliers, the Malmaison and a few boutique hotels in Leith offer “luxury on a budget” – often in the £140-£180 range. So an average of around £150 is a fair estimate for top-end accommodation in Leith. This is considerably less than luxury properties in the city centre. Essentially, your money can buy more luxury in Leith (albeit with fewer options to choose from).

Final Summary & Comparison

In summary, Edinburgh has a variety of excellent neighborhoods for travelers, each with its own flavor. All of the areas above are safe and well-regarded – you really can’t go too wrong with any of them. It comes down to what experience you want: staying amidst medieval history in Old Town, enjoying Georgian elegance and shopping in New Town, finding a quiet convenient base in the West End, living local in Stockbridge, or soaking up the hip waterfront vibe in Leith. Here’s a quick comparison of the key points and average prices in each area:

No matter where you stay, Edinburgh’s size means you’re never far from the rest of the city. Buses, trams, and affordable taxis make it easy to explore all these neighborhoods during your visit. For example, you can stay in peaceful Stockbridge and still have dinner in the Old Town, or stay in Leith and sightsee in New Town by day, without much hassle. Each of these areas will give you a wonderful experience – it’s all about matching the neighborhood’s character to your personal travel style. Enjoy your time in Edinburgh!